Sociedad Anonima Damm v Hijos De Rivera, S.A. [2022] SGIPOS 6

31 August 2022

Sociedad Anonima Damm v Hijos De Rivera, S.A. [2022] SGIPOS 6

The Applicant, Hijos de Rivera, S.A. and the Opponent, Sociedad Anonima Damm are beer producers based in Spain. Both parties co-exist in Spain, Europe and UK, but as they grew beyond those territories they began to get embroiled in disputes.  

The Opponent registered its word mark “ESTRELLA DAMM” (“Registered Mark”) in Singapore in 2011, beginning its sale of beer soon after. Subsequently, the Applicant also commenced business in Singapore, but only applied to register its Composite Mark Logo, company name

Description automatically generatedsome time later, on 24 April 2019, under International Registration No. 1166479 (Singapore Trademark No. 40201910153U) in Class 32 for beer (“Application Mark”). Sociedad opposed this, relying on sections 8(2)(b), 8(4)(b)(i) and 8(7)(a) of the Trade Marks Act 1998 (the “Act”).  

On the first ground of confusingly similar mark, the IP Adjudicator assessed both marks and found them to be visually, aurally and conceptually dissimilar.  He rejected the Opponent’s argument that the dominant and distinctive feature of the marks was “ESTRELLA” and opined instead that the average consumer in Singapore would view both marks in their entirety as opposed to focusing only on the common first element “ESTRELLA”.  Since both marks are found to be dissimilar, there was no need to look into the likelihood of confusion and the opposition failed on this ground.  

On the Opponent’s argument that the Application Mark should not be allowed to proceed to registration as it was similar to its Registered Mark which was well-known, the IP Adjudicator was not persuaded by the evidence adduced by the Opponent to prove that its Registered Mark was well-known.  On the contrary, due to the lack of specificity and substantiation, he was led to conclude that advertising efforts and sales of the Opponent’s products in Singapore were insignificant and insufficient to establish that its Registered Mark was well-known.  The opposition on this ground accordingly failed. 

Finally, in relation to passing off, while it was undisputed that the Opponent had acquired goodwill in its business in Singapore, since the IP Adjudicator had concluded earlier that the marks were dissimilar, taking into consideration all the arguments put forth by the parties, he concluded that there was no likelihood of confusion. 

More importantly, seeing as parties had co-existed in Singapore for at least seven (7) years before the commencement of the opposition proceedings, and the fact that the Opponent had not produced a single instance of confusion from consumers or traders, the IP Adjudicator concluded that there was an absence of actual confusion and consequently, there is unlikely to be any confusion in the future if the Application Mark was allowed to be registered.  For this reason, he failed the opposition on this ground and allowed the Application Mark to proceed to registration. 

About the author

 Denise Mirandah

Denise Mirandah

As a Director, Denise Mirandah has played a major role in the international promotion of the company, helping to share the family values of Mirandah Asia and its successful one-stop shop approach to IP with clients all over the world.

Denise has had a passion for IP from an early age and, as the daughter of Patrick and Gladys Mirandah, grew up in a household where IP was discussed regularly. She studied her Bachelor of Laws at the prestigious Cambridge University in the UK. There, she underwent rigorous academic training with the world’s most eminent legal minds, including Professor Bill Cornish, a renowned authority on IP law.

During her summer holidays, she attended Harvard University in the US to hone her drafting skills and familiarise herself with the American legal system, voluntarily working as part of Harvard’s pro bono programme in Boston.

Denise has been admitted to the Bar in Singapore since 2009, and in Brunei as of 2017.

Law firms

Law firms

Please wait while the page is loading...